Your Guide to Radiant Floor Heating: The Pros and Cons

Your Guide to Radiant Floor Heating The Pros and Cons - Sebring Services

When winter ends for most folks in this country, some home owners, tired of paying large power bills, may be considering the idea of a more efficient heating system for their home.  I’m all for that and want to help you make some good decisions if you decide you’re ready to move on that idea.  After all, this is one of those projects we call an “investment” as it represents a major change in the way your house will function and, more importantly, represents a substantial improvement in your comfort.  It’s also a good time to be thinking about remodeling as summer approaches and contractors are looking for projects.

With that said, here are the answers to questions about radiant heating that you’ll want for your current or new home.

1. How is a Radiant Floor Heating System Better than the Conventional Forced Air System?

Comparing the two is like comparing a horse and buggy with an automobile. The Radiant Heat system technology is miles ahead of the forced air system in many ways:

Performance Conventional Gas or Electrical Forced Air Radiant Heat
Heating Efficiency Temperature differs from floor to ceiling and wall to wall Consistent temperature throughout the space
Air Quality Broadcasts dust, dirt, odors Air remains uncontaminated
Performance Adjustments Adjust vents & temp to compensate for weather changes No noise
Ambience Fan and duct noise One-time setting
Maintenance Filter changing – Repairs No maintenance/repairs
Moving Parts Countless Countless None
Cost to Run No improvement in life-cycle Begins to save money with time

2. Why Use Radiant Heating?

You’ve heard of it, but need more information before you can really study the subject.  So here’s why you want to consider it:

You may have noticed how the sun’s rays feel especially good on a cold day, almost as if they’re attracted to you.  That’s how radiant heat operates:  it finds you!

It concentrates at lower levels in a space, where you are, as opposed to warm air that floats up to the ceiling, where you are not.  So your feet and legs are warm for a change.

It’s quiet, no fans or motors humming away, spreading dust and bacteria. No drafts will find their way into the airstream, no airstream!

Each room is heated in response to how it’s being used.  Think of the efficiency with this feature.  You can set the temperature of each room depending on the activity and most importantly, the number of windows that otherwise throw an HVAC’s efforts into working harder to compensate—perhaps in rooms where it’s not even needed.Radiant  heating can be designed to satisfy the functions and occupancy in each individual room, for example:  baths, additions, kitchen, second floor rooms above the garage and many other rooms subjected to outside exposure because of their location.

The installation cost is substantial, but experience has shown they will pay for themselves with reduced power bills in the years to come.  Take a look at this Naperville master bathroom project we did using Warmly Yours radiant floor heating.

3. What is Radiant Heat?

Radiant floor heating originates from tubing mounted on a fire resistant platform under the floor.  The design differs from a wall design in that it is integrated within a composition to the degree that it functions in one direction, up.

The principle behind radiant heat has to do with how temperature behaves.  There wants to be a balance between hot and cold molecules in any contained space, provided there is no other influence.  When one or the other is augmented however and an imbalance is created, and the augmented temperature gains dominance, in the case of heat it will flow toward the ceiling, while cold will fall to the floor.  Radiant heat differs somewhat when you come into contact with it.  A good example is when one of the electric coils on the range is on, gives off heat and you can feel it as you come within a certain distance, it is actually radiating heat 360°.   Turn on all 4 coils and it practically heats up a small kitchen to a noticeable change in ambient temperature. Attach similar coil material to a backing and connect it to a control and you have radiant.

Radiant Heating - ImagineEnergy - Sebring Services

Provided from: ImagineEnergy.net

4. How Does Radiant Floor Heating Work?

So that in place of a fan that distributes warm air, the radiant floor system uses the natural movement of heat that passes directly into the room from the platform in the floor.  Similar to the warm sunlight in the winter the entire floor is engaged as a heating device and once reaching the range of 70-72 degrees warms the whole space with an even distribution according to the thermostat signals.  Now you have a consistently comfortable space with no moving parts to cause concern and no noise to hear.  One of the best features of this system is its maintenance-free configuration.  Being entirely enclosed in the floor keeps it in pristine condition to last indefinitely.  You set the desired performance.

The two types of heated flooring systems are electric radiant heated floors and hydronic heated floor:

  1. Electric radiant heat is provided by electric under-floor heating cables.
  2. Hydronic radiant floor heating system, with the help of a boiler, generates hot water, then pumps it through plastic PEX tubing installed underneath the surface to be heated.

Both systems rely on a proper design that produces  an even heat  and set  at the best temperature for the space.

Both systems consist of a continuous series of tubing under the floor  and administered by a thermostat that responds to sensors.  This system is what promotes a consistent environment with floors maintaining the best temperature for your family’s comfort. Which one is best for your project? It depends  on who is performing the installation.

5. What are the Pros of Radiant Floor Heating?

The main benefit of radiant floor heating is the accuracy of its affect–an even temperature throughout the space that, once set to your comfort, needs no adjustment during the cold season.  The space is just as warm at head height as it is at your feet.  No adjusting the thermostat or vents to accommodate the occupants or respond to weather conditions.  You’re able to maintain a consistant power bill as well and before you know it, the system will have paid for itself with money saved.  Best of all, no worries about system repairs or replacement.  With no moving parts, the system remains completely in tact at all times.

6. What are the Cons of Radiant Floor Heating?

Home owners need to be prepared to replace the floors in their existing home which is a considerable expense and often a deal breaker.  Unless the floor can be accessed from underneath between floor joists, there are no other options.  However, if you’re building a new home, or have plans to replace the floors in a remodeling project, happy day!  Easily installed before final floor covering is put down.

Cable vs. Mat Installation

There has been some discussion regarding the preferred way to install the radiant cable.

To give home owners an idea of the discussion we are providing the following information to increase your knowledge toward a good decision when the opportunity arises to purchase one or the other.

The main contrast between a cable and mat radiant system is the way the cable is handled in each case.

If you’re a do-it-yourselfer, who doesn’t mind devoting one Saturday to keep $200 in your bank account (about the difference between 200 sq. ft. of cable vs. mat) then choose cable. However, if you’re a general contractor who needs the crew in, out, and on to the next hot project sooner rather than later. Finally, if you’re an independent tradesman a lot rides on how well you plan your days, but all three are decisions based on the choice of a version of this brilliant device for heating your rooms with the most efficient heating system on the planet.

In the cable system, the cable is loose and can be designed in several different ways.  Whereas the mat system is pre-designed on a surface to be cut in sections and then applied.  You might agree that the mat system will take less time as you can cut and fit sections within an area more quickly than taking the time to design a loose cable system.  Particularly in a room that contains 200 square feet or so.  So does it always work out that the mat version saves time?  When you consider a smaller room, such as a 40 square foot bathroom and you have a different challenge that seems easily handled with the loose cable system that can be manipulated around objects in the room whereas a mat would be difficult.  Time saved under these circumstances.   Trying to fit a mat around the commode or out into the room to fit up to the shower or around a tub on a curved plantoform would require some special skills if you were to choose a mat installation.  Wise to look at the room and decide which configuration is best suited, paying attention to size and shapes when making the decision.

Not the least of which is cost when considering which system you want to choose.  With less material involved it’s natural that the loose cable would cost less than the mat embedded version.  The bigger the space the more you save with the cable.  But there is a compensation when it comes to a larger room if you decide the use the mat version.  It will take far less time to install, so with that in mind, you will be making the choice based on how valuable you think your time is.

At the end of the day, if you are an avid DIY person who can devote a week-end to save $200 (plus or minus the difference between 200 sq. ft of cable vs. mat, you might choose the cable.  Were you a general contractor with several crews to move between jobs, you will most certainly choose the mat version.  Whereas an independent tradesman will make a more fine-tuned decision.  How much is the home owner committed to saving money?  Or how much time do you feel you can devote to a little one-room project?

Check out this article: Flooring Face-Off: Engineered Flooring vs. Hardwood Flooring.

7. Who Distributes Electric Radiant Floor Heat?

Distributor Product 1 Product 2 Product 3 Warranty
NuHeat

Nuheat Floor Heating Systems keep tile, stone, granite, marble, and slate surfaces at just-right temperatures.

Tile/stone

radiant installation

Laminate Shower/

Custom Mats

25 years
Warmly Yours

WarmlyYours also provides design services

Tile/stone

concrete

installation

Laminate Wood 25 years
Suntouch Floor heating mats Floor heating wire UnderFloor Heating 25 years
Schluter

DITRA-HEAT

DITRA-HEAT is the only system that provides floor warming and uncoupling in a single layer. Tile/stone

installation

Wood:

Natural

engineered

Conditional 25 years
Thermosoft Ceramic/stone

tile installation

Laminate & wood installation Carpet & vinyl tile Lifetime warranty
Heatizon Tile and stone floor installation Heated hardwood floors Heated carpet floors

Heated floating floors

Various

See website for each product

Quiet Warmth For radiant heated traditional tile floors, glue-down floors, and engineered wood floors. Not intended for use under natural stones. Comes in two convenient sizes: 3′ x 5′ covering 15 S.F and 3′ x 10′ covering. Installation instructions on website
Warmup

Warmup Floor Heating Systems and 4iE Smart Thermostat keep tile, stone, carpet, laminate and even vinyl at just-right temperatures.

Tile/stone
installation
Laminate Shower/custom mats 30 years

 

8. How do I Install Radiant Heating System Under Carpet?

Floor heating installation under carpet, as suggested by Warm Zone, Inc.:

  1. Attach the the components to the subfloor, taking care that they do not come into any contact with one another; you can accomplish this by applying staples, specified tape or latex modified morter to hold them in place as you install them.  (Avoid using adhesives—they can interfere with the functional performance of the semi-conductive components.)
  2. Be especially careful not to penetrate on either side of the components with nails or any other sharp fixing object because, again, a short circuit could result and become a fire hazard.
  3. Once the electrical contacts are accomplished, route the wires to the transformer, as instructed by the manufacturer as well as following electrical and local regulations.
  4. The wires can be located on the floor, for conventional foundations, or under the substrate.
  5. Cover the components and install the flooring above as instructed by the manufacturer.

Your Guide to Radiant Floor Heating The Pros and Cons - Sebring Services9. How do I Install Radiant Floor Heating Under Tile?

If a home owner decides to install this floor we advise a comprehensive consultation with the distributor to learn all the details of installation before attempting the project.  Schluter has provided an excellent example of a  comprehensive installation manual and warranty criteria; please download this manual and study it in preparation for your consultation with your distributor.  There is also a video on their website we urge you to view and help you identify various items addressed in the installation instructions.

It is critical to note the materials requirements and be certain you can obtain the exact specification so that the tile format is appropriate for the installation.

  1. The minimum tile size is 2″ x 2″ (5 cm x 5 cm).
  2. Be certain the foundation is pristine, plum and adheres to the load-bearing specification to be certain that the surface is level.
  3. The mortar specified is “thin-set” to be applied to the foundation platform. The mortar mixture needs to be easily manipulated by a ¼” x ¼” square-notched trowel.
  4. With fleece-side facing down, apply it to the foundation, firmly integrating the matting into the mortar via a float, screed trowel, or obtain a DITRA-ROLLER. It is important to wait the open time of the bonding-mortar. Should the mortar “skin” over before the matting installation, remove it and reapply.

Schluter informs us that it may be an advantage to “back-roll the end of the matting before installation, or place boxes of tile on top of the matting after installation, to avoid curling.” Recommended by Schluter:   *When using the DITRA-ROLLER, place a weight (e.g., bags of mortar/grout or box of tile) not to exceed 75 lbs on the DITRA-ROLLER shelf. Slowly move the roller from one end of the matting to the other, slightly overlapping successive passes.

  1. Check mortar at a corner of the matting to be sure full contact has been achieved between fleece webbing the the mortar. Note that coverage may differ depending on mortar consistency, angle of trowel, foundation’s surface, etc..  Remove and reapply if coverage is faulty; must be consistent all the way across the surface.
  2. Match end and side sections of adjacent mats and align studs on the top of matting while installing so as to assist with facilitating cable installation.
  3. The cables can be installed and tile can be installed directly over the membrane after the cables have been installed using an “unmodified” think-set. The manual contains these instructions.

10. How do I Install Radiant Heat Under Laminate Flooring?

  1. The first thing to do is arrange the radiant floor warming pads to fit in the area you want to heat.
  2. In the unheated areas use Insulayment or alternative underlayment pad.
  3. Connect floor temperature sensor and bring the lead wires from the end of each pad to the electric box.
  4. Install thermostat and make electrical connections.
  5. Glue the mats to the subfloor, then glue the laminate or wood floor to the “ThermoFloor”.
  6. Install floor using manufacturer’s instructions.

11. Which Flooring Materials Work Best with Radiant Heat?

You can consider that all flooring materials will work with radiant floors.  However some will facilitate the system more efficiently than their counterparts. It’s best to think of this under certain circumstances—to be more specific—for the best answer.

  1. Ceramic tile, stone and concrete have thermal-conducting properties, that allow it to perform well, are known to conduct, which conduct, transfer, and handle  heat effectively while concurrently maintaining a consistent temperature.
  2. With their inclination to expand and contract with variable temperatures the installer will have rememdies applied to compensate for this action.

**Extensive laboratory testing by Launstein Hardwood Floors in Mason, Mich., found that American hardwoods – including cherry, oak, ash, maple, hickory and walnut – are good choices for radiant-heat flooring.

  1. Vinyl and plastic exhibit temperature boundaries, while carpets will have variable spacing.
  2. By consensus, the material most often recommended is tile.  It’s regular features and heat resistance beng the commanding attributes.
  3. When chosen, concrete will perform well when using a hydronic system, integrated within the concrete as it’s poured from a concrete company.
  4. Manufacturers agree that wood, carpet and tile will respond positively to hydronic heat. Be certain careful planning is accomplished when designing with this type of heat, and consult the distributor for peak performance..

12. How Much Does a Radiant Heat System Cost?

Category Low Estimate High Estimate
2000 square foot residence with open/direct system.
40 hour Labor Allotment
2000 square ft joisted floor area $1,700.00 $3,000.00
Two heating zones $1,200.00 $1,450.00
Boiler or water heater allowance $3,000.00 $3,500.00
Total $5,900.00 $7,950.00

Check out our Other Great Articles:

 

Sources:

 

 

Blog-CTA-Banner-3_Sebring-Services
2017-07-21T08:56:34+00:00Categories: Homeowner Tips|Tags: |15 Comments

About the Author:

" We are very passionate about educating homeowners. From design ideas to hiring a contractor, we hope this blog helps you in the process of remodeling your home. " ~ Bryan Sebring

15 Comments

  1. Wade Joel May 19, 2016 at 2:16 pm - Reply

    I liked your first chart that clearly explains the differences between forced air heating and radiant floor heating. I did not know that radiant heating maintains a consistent temperature through the whole space. Thank you for the awesome article on radiant heating!

  2. Judy Wilson June 6, 2016 at 5:11 pm - Reply

    I’ve thought about installing a radiant floor heating system in my home, so I could use some pointers about the materials that would be best to use. You said that ceramic tile, stone, and concrete have thermal-conducting properties. I’m glad that I know that so that I can choose the right flooring material to handle heat effectively. I’ll consider using one of these three materials before having it installed.

  3. Sarah Smith July 6, 2016 at 3:29 pm - Reply

    I remodeling my kitchen and am thinking about installing some heating cables beneath the new tile. Thanks for the advice about how the heat cables are easy to install yourself. I’ll have to see if I can buy some cables for a decent price from a company that will also give me pointers on how to install and maintain them.

  4. Sarah Anderson July 14, 2016 at 10:39 am - Reply

    I love the idea of a heated floor. Not having to stip-step on the cold wood with bare feet in the morning would be nice. Plus, since heat rises, having your heating element throughout the floor just makes it rise and warm the entire place.

  5. Lauren Woodley July 14, 2016 at 1:07 pm - Reply

    It’s nice to know that tile floors work best with in floor heating. I want to get wood throughout my house, and it’s nice that there are tile materials that look like wood that are available. This way, I can have the heating system put in and I can still have the wood floor look! Thank you for sharing.

  6. Kendall Ryder August 9, 2016 at 10:24 am - Reply

    I get cold super easy. Even when it is warm out. I think that radiant floor heating would be wonderful for me! That way I don’t have to worry about always wearing socks inside so my feet don’t get cold. I hate stepping on hardwood floors that are freezing!

  7. James Bergman August 10, 2016 at 4:06 pm - Reply

    I really appreciate your going through the pros and cons of radiant heating. I really like that it is better at keeping temperatures in a room even. I also think it would make walking around barefoot in the bathroom or the kitchen much more comfortable.

  8. emily bennette September 8, 2016 at 8:03 pm - Reply

    This is some really good information about radiant floor heating. I like the idea of having my bathroom floors be warm on a cold winter morning. I am glad that you also went over what types of floor materials this works with. It is nice that it works well with tiles and concrete.

  9. Fred Gravel June 4, 2017 at 8:49 pm - Reply

    Keeping this article handy for when we renovate our master bathroom. The wife and I have been saying we wish we had heated floors since we build our house in 1998. Ohio winters can be brutal on the tootsies when you’ve got ceramic tiles. This time around, we will be installing radiant heat!

  10. Bobby Saint December 6, 2017 at 10:32 pm - Reply

    I like that you provided some insights on the benefits of radiant floor heating such as being able to adjust the temperature of each room according to your personal preference. It surely is an advantage especially if you have many rooms in the house being occupied by different people in the household. Plus, it’s extremely quiet and no motors are needed. I would definitely consider installing radiant floor heating in my house if we ever plan to do some remodeling. Thanks.

  11. Victoria Thomas February 6, 2018 at 6:43 am - Reply

    Thanks for all the details. Radiant floor heating keeps rooms warm, doesn’t make any noise and it’s energy efficient.

  12. Adam Strange May 2, 2018 at 12:37 am - Reply

    Thank you for sharing such great information. It’s a pleasure to visit here.

  13. Duncan Lance July 6, 2018 at 3:19 pm - Reply

    There are a ton of benefits that you can gain from in-floor heating and it is great that your article goes over them. I think it is especially nice that it brings up the fact that in-floor heating provides a consistent heat. That way you do not have to worry about adjusting the thermostat once you’ve found the perfect heat that you want.

  14. Tim September 19, 2018 at 1:35 am - Reply

    Nice idea for floor heating system, this is very useful.

  15. Andrew Agar October 15, 2018 at 8:45 am - Reply

    This is an investment that pays off amazingly.

Leave A Comment